{"id":7850,"date":"2025-02-12T12:32:26","date_gmt":"2025-02-12T11:32:26","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/www.cr-online.de\/blog\/?p=7850"},"modified":"2025-02-17T11:21:01","modified_gmt":"2025-02-17T10:21:01","slug":"berlin-court-rules-on-art-4012-dsa-with-broader-lessons-for-private-enforcement-of-the-dsa","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/www.cr-online.de\/blog\/2025\/02\/12\/berlin-court-rules-on-art-4012-dsa-with-broader-lessons-for-private-enforcement-of-the-dsa\/","title":{"rendered":"Berlin court rules on Art. 40(12) DSA &#8211; with broader lessons for private enforcement of the DSA"},"content":{"rendered":"<p><span style=\"font-weight: 400;\">On February 6th 2025, at the regional court of Berlin (Landgericht Berlin II),Claimant Democracy Reporting International (DRI) has won a preliminary injunction against X (see <\/span><a href=\"https:\/\/www.politico.eu\/article\/berlin-court-orders-x-hand-over-election-data-legal-blow-elon-musk-platform\/\"><span style=\"font-weight: 400;\">politico<\/span><\/a><span style=\"font-weight: 400;\">).\u00a0<\/span><\/p>\n<p><span style=\"font-weight: 400;\">The platform must now enable unrestricted access (\u201cunbeschr\u00e4nkten Zugang\u201d) to publicly accessible platform data.<\/span><\/p>\n<p><b>Background\u00a0<\/b><\/p>\n<p><span style=\"font-weight: 400;\">Claimant DRI is aiming at effective data access for signals of engagement (e.g. shares, likes etc. of certain tweets over time etc.) to study online discourse prior German election this month (<\/span><a href=\"https:\/\/democracy-reporting.org\/en\/office\/EU\/news\/court-orders-x-to-allow-our-research-on-the-german-elections\"><span style=\"font-weight: 400;\">link<\/span><\/a><span style=\"font-weight: 400;\">). DRI has gained attention with similar analysis in the context of other elections (e.g. Romania).<\/span><\/p>\n<p><span style=\"font-weight: 400;\">Some press reports about the case are a little bit missing the point of this case: It is not about data access in itself, it is about effective access.\u00a0<\/span><span style=\"font-weight: 400;\">Because interestingly, the relevant X-data is publicly available, so one could say: Why sue? Why not just look at the tweets?\u00a0<\/span><\/p>\n<p><span style=\"font-weight: 400;\">But researchers need better, more effective access through APIs to automatically and systematically extract such data. Mysterious Art. 40(12) DSA helps: To give researchers <\/span><span style=\"font-weight: 400;\">more effective access<\/span><span style=\"font-weight: 400;\"> than just manually looking at the data, e.g. by not preventing scraping (<em>Maamar<\/em>, in: Kraul, Das neue Recht der digitalen Dienste, 2023, \u00a7 4 Rn.\u00a0<\/span><span style=\"font-weight: 400;\">245). Recital 98 S. 1 DSA supports this assumption: <em>Using<\/em> data to understand systematic risks can hardly be done by manually looking at online interactions (as a normal user would do). And the Commission thinks so too, as it suspects a violation of Art. 40(12) DSA as follows: \u201cX prohibits eligible researchers from independently accessing its public data, such as by scraping, as stated in its terms of service.\u201d (<\/span><a href=\"https:\/\/ec.europa.eu\/commission\/presscorner\/detail\/en\/ip_24_3761\"><span style=\"font-weight: 400;\">link<\/span><\/a><span style=\"font-weight: 400;\">).\u00a0<\/span><\/p>\n<p><span style=\"font-weight: 400;\">Especially with X, some researchers mourn that Twitter had provided a pretty good API for data access, which X now has shut down. <\/span><\/p>\n<p><span style=\"font-weight: 400;\">Can Art. 40(12) DSA bring back \u201ceffective access\u201d?<\/span><\/p>\n<p><b>The Berlin Court ruling<\/b><\/p>\n<p><span style=\"font-weight: 400;\">The court ruling is a preliminary injunction (LG Berlin II, 6 February 2025 &#8211; 41 O 140\/25). The court issued it without prior oral hearing, and, as it seems, did not hear X during the proceeding (immediate order), which is possible in urgent cases. The court ordered X to enable\u00a0unrestricted access (\u201cunbeschr\u00e4nkten Zugang\u201d) to publicly accessible platform data.<\/span><span style=\"font-weight: 400;\">\u00a0<\/span><\/p>\n<p><span style=\"font-weight: 400;\"><span style=\"text-decoration: underline;\">Note:<\/span> Some press reports implied a misunderstanding of the ruling. The court did NOT order a procedural fine of 6.000 Euro against X (as reported by <\/span><a href=\"https:\/\/www.politico.eu\/article\/berlin-court-orders-x-hand-over-election-data-legal-blow-elon-musk-platform\/\"><span style=\"font-weight: 400;\">politico<\/span><\/a><span style=\"font-weight: 400;\">), this is a misunderstanding (the value of the proceeding was set to 6.000 Euro, which is a basis for assessing lawyers and court fees).<\/span><\/p>\n<p><span style=\"font-weight: 400;\">Typical for injunctions, the written reasons are just a few sentences. Here are the 3 main points:<\/span><\/p>\n<ul>\n<li style=\"font-weight: 400;\"><span style=\"font-weight: 400;\">In one sentence, they say that DRI is likely to have a claim under Art. 54, 40(12) DSA (likelihood of success on the merits).\u00a0<\/span><\/li>\n<li style=\"font-weight: 400;\"><span style=\"font-weight: 400;\">Also in one sentence, the court explains its international jurisdiction to follow from Art. 7 Nr. 2 Brussels Ia.\u00a0<\/span><\/li>\n<li style=\"font-weight: 400;\"><span style=\"font-weight: 400;\">The case is urgent enough for an injunction, as German elections are ahead this month and X had not responded to prior requests to data access.<\/span><\/li>\n<\/ul>\n<p>What happens next:\u00a0<span style=\"font-weight: 400;\">X now can request review by the same 1st instance court, and following that could appeal to the appellate court of Berlin.<\/span><\/p>\n<p><b>Lessons beyond Art. 40(12) DSA<\/b><\/p>\n<p><span style=\"font-weight: 400;\">Obviously, researchers will welcome the court order. <\/span><span style=\"font-weight: 400;\">In my view, there are interesting implications which go far beyond Art. 40(12) DSA:<\/span><\/p>\n<p><b>Specific performance as a remedy under Art. 54 DSA<\/b><\/p>\n<p><span style=\"font-weight: 400;\">The court implies\u00a0 that if a platform violates a due diligence obligation, then &#8211; through Art. 54 DSA &#8211; the remedy is not just monetary compensation, but also to conduct the obligation in itself (specific performance). Through this logic, private litigation might force platforms, e.g., to put-back accounts (Art. 20(4) S. 2 DSA) or to block repeat-infringers (Art. 23(1) DSA).\u00a0<\/span><\/p>\n<p><span style=\"font-weight: 400;\">From a German perspective, this is not so surprising. However, some voices had doubted whether Art. 54 DSA could yield specific performance as a remedy, while others had supported this (e.g. NK-DSA\/<em>Raue<\/em>, 1. Aufl. 2023, DSA Art. 54 Rn. 52; I had argued so in MMR 2023, 643). Of course, the exact contours of private enforcement through Art. 54 DSA still remain to be clarified in the future.\u00a0<\/span><\/p>\n<p>(On a side note: This should be a wake-up call to DSCs too, as they often pretend not to have powers to order specific performance, e.g. a specific put-back, while of course through Art. 51(2)(b) DSA they have, as I had argued earlier in\u00a0<span class=\"highlight\">MMR<\/span>\u00a02023, 643).<\/p>\n<p><b>A door towards \u201cmore\u201d cross-border jurisdiction under Art. 7 Nr. 2 Brussels Ia?<\/b><\/p>\n<p>If Art. 54 DSA yields obligations of specific performance, this should go hand in hand with another\u00a0<span style=\"font-weight: 400;\">substantial consequence: International jurisdictions of the countries of residence of recipients so that users must not go to Ireland to sue, but can sue \u201cat home\u201d.<\/span><\/p>\n<p><span style=\"font-weight: 400;\">The Berlin court assumes international jurisdiction under Art. 7 Nr. 2 Brussels Ia. This is in line with the CJEU\u2019s broad understanding here: \u201cIt is the Court\u2019s settled case-law that the concept of \u2018matters relating to tort, delict or quasi-delict\u2019 within the meaning of point 2 of Article 7 of Regulation No 1215\/2012 covers all actions which seek to establish the liability of a defendant and do not concern matters relating to a contract \u2026, that is to say, actions not based on a legal obligation freely consented to by one person towards another\u201d (C\u201159\/19, para 23).<\/span><\/p>\n<p><span style=\"font-weight: 400;\">Let us assume that the CJEU will stick to this very broad and uncompromising understanding of Art. 7 Nr. 2 Brussels Ia (I have some mild doubts, but l leave them aside here).\u00a0<\/span><\/p>\n<p><span style=\"font-weight: 400;\">Now keep in mind that the DSA in many ways complements contractual obligations through statutory due diligence obligations (e.g. put-back, through Art. 20(4) S. 2 DSA). Until today, these contractual obligations (e.g. put-back) could establish international jurisdiction only through Art. 7 Nr. 1 Brussels Ia, which regularly lead to the country of residence of the provider (often: Ireland). With many platforms therefore, users need to sue in Ireland (see <\/span><a href=\"https:\/\/eujs.org\/press-releases\/twittertrial-x-finds-loophole-strategic-lawsuit-only-possible-in-ireland\/\"><span style=\"font-weight: 400;\">here<\/span><\/a><span style=\"font-weight: 400;\"> and <\/span><a href=\"https:\/\/hateaid.org\/fuer-freie-forschung-grundsatzprozess-travis-brown-gegen-x\/#1698416841394-409829fc-a7d1\"><span style=\"font-weight: 400;\">here<\/span><\/a><span style=\"font-weight: 400;\"> for prominent cases).<\/span><\/p>\n<p><span style=\"font-weight: 400;\">Now where the DSA adds statutory due diligence (e.g. Art. 20(4) S. 2 DSA), this will lead to damages under Art. 54 DSA, and as we have seen with the Berlin ruling, a remedy of specific performance, which, again as implied in the Berlin ruling, would fall under Art. 7(2) Brussels Ia, and thus yield international jurisdiction for courts in the country of residence of the user.<\/span><\/p>\n<p><span style=\"font-weight: 400;\">I admit that there are still some complicated discussions possible, but the path forward as implied by the Berlin court is clearly raising chances to establish jurisdiction in your home country (side note: It might still be preferable to have a statutory clarification similar to Art. 79 (2) GDPR). <\/span><\/p>\n<p>&nbsp;<\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"<p>On February 6th 2025, at the regional court of Berlin (Landgericht Berlin II),Claimant Democracy Reporting International (DRI) has won a preliminary injunction against X (see politico).\u00a0 The platform must now enable unrestricted access (\u201cunbeschr\u00e4nkten Zugang\u201d) to publicly accessible platform data. Background\u00a0 Claimant DRI is aiming at effective data access for signals of engagement (e.g. shares, [&hellip;]<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":5267,"featured_media":0,"comment_status":"open","ping_status":"closed","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":[],"categories":[1],"tags":[],"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.cr-online.de\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/7850"}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.cr-online.de\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.cr-online.de\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.cr-online.de\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/5267"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.cr-online.de\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=7850"}],"version-history":[{"count":6,"href":"https:\/\/www.cr-online.de\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/7850\/revisions"}],"predecessor-version":[{"id":7868,"href":"https:\/\/www.cr-online.de\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/7850\/revisions\/7868"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.cr-online.de\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=7850"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.cr-online.de\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=7850"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.cr-online.de\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=7850"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}