{"id":2480,"date":"2015-05-07T18:05:44","date_gmt":"2015-05-07T17:05:44","guid":{"rendered":"http:\/\/www.cr-online.de\/blog\/?p=2480"},"modified":"2015-07-15T13:45:58","modified_gmt":"2015-07-15T12:45:58","slug":"gegen-bulk-collection-und-selektoren-us-buergerrechtler-gewinnen-in-zweiter-instanz-gegen-nsa","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/www.cr-online.de\/blog\/2015\/05\/07\/gegen-bulk-collection-und-selektoren-us-buergerrechtler-gewinnen-in-zweiter-instanz-gegen-nsa\/","title":{"rendered":"Gegen &#8222;Bulk Collection&#8220; und &#8222;Selektoren&#8220;: US-B\u00fcrgerrechtler gewinnen in zweiter Instanz gegen NSA"},"content":{"rendered":"<p>Die amerikanische B\u00fcrgerrechtsorganisation ACLU hat heute einen wichtigen Erfolg erzielt. Der United States Court of Appeals for the Second\u00a0Circuit hat einer Klage der ACLU gegen die NSA stattgegeben und erkl\u00e4rt die fl\u00e4chendeckende Sammlung von Metadaten (Verkehrsdaten) f\u00fcr rechtswidrig erkl\u00e4rt (<a href=\"http:\/\/pdfserver.amlaw.com\/nlj\/NSA_ca2_20150507.pdf\" target=\"_blank\"><em>ACLU v. Clapper<\/em>, decision of 7 May 2015, <span style=\"font-family: PalatinoLinotype-Roman; font-size: large;\">Docket No. 14<\/span><span lang=\"JA\" style=\"font-family: PalatinoLinotype-Roman; font-size: large;\">\u2010<\/span><span style=\"font-family: PalatinoLinotype-Roman; font-size: large;\">42<\/span><span lang=\"JA\" style=\"font-family: PalatinoLinotype-Roman; font-size: large;\">\u2010<\/span><span style=\"font-family: PalatinoLinotype-Roman; font-size: large;\">cv<\/span><\/a>). Das heutige Urteil ist nicht zuletzt deshalb auch f\u00fcr uns interessant, weil es um \u201cSelektoren\u201d geht, die die NSA einsetzt. \u201eSelektoren\u201c stehen im Mittelpunkt der aktuellen Berichte \u00fcber eine Zusammenarbeit zwischen dem BND und der NSA.<\/p>\n<p><strong>Vorgehensweise der NSA<\/strong><\/p>\n<p>Die NSA sammelt seit Jahren fl\u00e4chendeckend Metadaten und durchsucht diese Daten (Telefonnummern, IP-Adressen usw.) mit Suchbegriffen (\u201eSelektoren\u201c). Wird die NSA f\u00fcndig (\u201eA hat am XX.XX.XXXX um XX.XX h mit B telefoniert\u201c), setzt sie die Suche mit Hilfe eines \u201eSelektors\u201c der Kontaktperson fort (\u201eB\u201c). Zeitweise erfolgte die Suche bis zur dritten Ebene (\u201eC, der Kontakt mit B hatte, der Kontakt mit A hatte.\u201c):<\/p>\n<blockquote><p>\u00a0\u201cThe government explains that it uses the bulk metadata collected pursuant to these orders by making \u201cqueries\u201d using metadata \u201cidentifiers\u201d (also referred to as \u201cselectors\u201d), or particular phone numbers that it believes, based on\u201creasonable articulable suspicion,\u201d to be associated with a foreign terrorist organization &#8230; The identifier is used as a \u201cseed\u201d to search across the government\u2019s database; the search results yield phone numbers, and the metadata associated with them, that have been in contact with the seed. Id. That step is referred to as the first \u201chop.\u201d The NSA can then also search for the numbers, and associated metadata, that have been in contact with the numbers resulting from the first search \u2013 conducting a second \u201chop &#8230; Until recently, the program allowed for another iteration of the process, such that a third \u201chop\u201d could be conducted, sweeping in results that include the metadata of, essentially, the contacts of contacts of contacts of the original \u201cseed.\u201d ..<strong>. <\/strong>The government asserts that it does not conduct any general\u201cbrowsing\u201d of the data&#8230;\u201d<br \/>\n(<a href=\"http:\/\/pdfserver.amlaw.com\/nlj\/NSA_ca2_20150507.pdf\" target=\"_blank\"><em>ACLU v. Clapper<\/em>, decision of 7 May 2015, <span style=\"font-family: PalatinoLinotype-Roman; font-size: large;\">Docket No. 14<\/span><span lang=\"JA\" style=\"font-family: PalatinoLinotype-Roman; font-size: large;\">\u2010<\/span><span style=\"font-family: PalatinoLinotype-Roman; font-size: large;\">42<\/span><span lang=\"JA\" style=\"font-family: PalatinoLinotype-Roman; font-size: large;\">\u2010<\/span><span style=\"font-family: PalatinoLinotype-Roman; font-size: large;\">cv, pages 17-18<\/span><\/a>)<\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p><strong>Parallele beim BND<\/strong><\/p>\n<p>Aus der Zeugenaussage der Datenschutzbeauftragten des BND vor dem NSA-Untersuchungsausschuss wissen wir, dass dem BND eine solche Vorgehensweise nicht fremd ist. Die Datenschutzbeauftragte berichtete von einem \u201eVerkehrsanalysesystem\u201c (VerAS), das der BND \u2013 ohne jede Rechtsgrundlage \u2013 bis in die f\u00fcnfte Beziehungsebene f\u00fchrt (vgl. <a href=\"http:\/\/www.cr-online.de\/blog\/2014\/10\/21\/veras-und-vorratsdatenspeicherung-bnd-im-rechtsfreien-raum\/\" target=\"_blank\">H\u00e4rting, &#8222;VerAS und Vorratsdatenspeicherung: BND im rechtsfreien Raum&#8220;, CRonline Blog v. 21.10.2014<\/a>).<\/p>\n<p>__________<br \/>\nAnzeige:<br \/>\n<a href=\"http:\/\/www.otto-schmidt.de\/internetrecht-1.html\"><img loading=\"lazy\" src=\"http:\/\/www.cr-online.de\/blog\/wp-content\/uploads\/2015\/02\/2015_03_HRI5-Ban-443x104.gif\" alt=\"\" width=\"443\" height=\"104\" \/><\/a><br \/>\n__________<\/p>\n<p><strong>Klagebefugnis der B\u00fcrgerrechtsorganisation<\/strong><\/p>\n<p>Der Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit\u00a0bejahte die Klagebefugnis der ACLU mit der Begr\u00fcndung, dass die Betroffenheit der Organisation hinreichend dargetan sei:<\/p>\n<blockquote><p>&#8222;Appellants challenge the telephone metadata program as a whole, alleging injury from the very collection of their telephone metadata. And, as the district court observed, it is not disputed that the government collected telephone metadata associated with the appellants\u2019 telephone calls. The Fourth Amendment protects against unreasonable searches <em>and seizures<\/em>. Appellants contend that the collection of their metadata exceeds the scope of what is authorized by \u00a7 215 and constitutes a Fourth Amendment search. We think such collection is more appropriately challenged, at least from a standing perspective, as a seizure rather than as a search. Whether or not such claims prevail on the merits, appellants surely have standing to allege injury from the collection, and maintenance in a government database, of records relating to them.&#8220;<br \/>\n(<a href=\"http:\/\/pdfserver.amlaw.com\/nlj\/NSA_ca2_20150507.pdf\" target=\"_blank\"><em>ACLU v. Clapper<\/em>, decision of 7 May 2015, <span style=\"font-family: PalatinoLinotype-Roman; font-size: large;\">Docket No. 14<\/span><span lang=\"JA\" style=\"font-family: PalatinoLinotype-Roman; font-size: large;\">\u2010<\/span><span style=\"font-family: PalatinoLinotype-Roman; font-size: large;\">42<\/span><span lang=\"JA\" style=\"font-family: PalatinoLinotype-Roman; font-size: large;\">\u2010<\/span><span style=\"font-family: PalatinoLinotype-Roman; font-size: large;\">cv, pages 27-28<\/span><\/a>)<\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p><strong>Keine NSA-Befugnis\u00a0nach Patriot Act &#8211; &#8222;Relevanz&#8220; von Daten<\/strong><\/p>\n<p>Nach \u00a7 215 Patriot Act ist die NSA befugt, von Providern die Herausgabe von Metadaten zu verlangen, wenn diese Daten f\u00fcr eine Untersuchung (\u201einvestigation\u201c) \u201erelevant\u201c sind. Die von der NSA vertretene Auffassung, dass <span style=\"text-decoration: underline;\">im Kampf gegen den Terror<\/span> jedes Datum \u201erelevant\u201c sei, \u00fcberzeugte das Berufungsgericht nicht:<\/p>\n<blockquote><p>&#8222;Thus, the government takes the position that the metadata collected \u2013 a vast amount of which does not contain directly \u201crelevant\u201d information, as the government concedes \u2013 are nevertheless \u201crelevant\u201d because they may allow the NSA, at some unknown time in the future, utilizing its ability to sift through the trove of irrelevant data it has collected up to that point, to identify information that <em>is <\/em>relevant.5 We agree with appellants that such an expansive concept of \u201crelevance\u201d is unprecedented and unwarranted.\u201d<br \/>\n(<a href=\"http:\/\/pdfserver.amlaw.com\/nlj\/NSA_ca2_20150507.pdf\" target=\"_blank\"><em>ACLU v. Clapper<\/em>, decision of 7 May 2015, <span style=\"font-family: PalatinoLinotype-Roman; font-size: large;\">Docket No. 14<\/span><span lang=\"JA\" style=\"font-family: PalatinoLinotype-Roman; font-size: large;\">\u2010<\/span><span style=\"font-family: PalatinoLinotype-Roman; font-size: large;\">42<\/span><span lang=\"JA\" style=\"font-family: PalatinoLinotype-Roman; font-size: large;\">\u2010<\/span><span style=\"font-family: PalatinoLinotype-Roman; font-size: large;\">cv, page 59<\/span><\/a>)<\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p><strong>Grundrechtsschutz: \u00a0schwierigste Frage<\/strong><\/p>\n<p>Da der Court of Appeals in \u00a7 215 des Patriot Act keine ausreichende Rechtsgrundlage sah, brauchte das Gericht nicht entscheiden, ob die Praxis der NSA verfassungskonform ist. Allerdings \u00e4u\u00dfert das Gericht deutliche Zweifel an der Verfassungskonformit\u00e4t:<\/p>\n<blockquote><p>&#8222;Appellants\u2019 argument invokes one of the most difficult issues in Fourth Amendment jurisprudence: the extent to which modern technology alters our traditional expectations of privacy. On the one hand, the very notion of an individual\u2019s expectation of privacy, considered in Katz a key component of the rights protected by the Fourth Amendment, may seem quaint in a world in which technology makes it possible for individuals and businesses (to say nothing of the government) to observe acts of individuals once regarded as protected from public view. On the other hand, rules that permit the government to obtain records and other information that consumers have shared with businesses without a warrant seem much more threatening as the extent of such information grows.\u201d<br \/>\n(<a href=\"http:\/\/pdfserver.amlaw.com\/nlj\/NSA_ca2_20150507.pdf\" target=\"_blank\"><em>ACLU v. Clapper<\/em>, decision of 7 May 2015, <span style=\"font-family: PalatinoLinotype-Roman; font-size: large;\">Docket No. 14<\/span><span lang=\"JA\" style=\"font-family: PalatinoLinotype-Roman; font-size: large;\">\u2010<\/span><span style=\"font-family: PalatinoLinotype-Roman; font-size: large;\">42<\/span><span lang=\"JA\" style=\"font-family: PalatinoLinotype-Roman; font-size: large;\">\u2010<\/span><span style=\"font-family: PalatinoLinotype-Roman; font-size: large;\">cv, pages 86<\/span><\/a>)<\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p><strong>Ausblick<\/strong><\/p>\n<p>Es ist damit zu rechnen, dass die US-Regierung Rechtsmittel einlegt und der Supreme Court den Fall abschlie\u00dfend entscheiden wird. Deutsche B\u00fcrgerrechtsorganisationen sollten sich jedenfalls ein Vorbild an der ACLU nehmen.<\/p>\n<p>&nbsp;<\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"<p>Die amerikanische B\u00fcrgerrechtsorganisation ACLU hat heute einen wichtigen Erfolg erzielt. Der United States Court of Appeals for the Second\u00a0Circuit hat einer Klage der ACLU gegen die NSA stattgegeben und erkl\u00e4rt die fl\u00e4chendeckende Sammlung von Metadaten (Verkehrsdaten) f\u00fcr rechtswidrig erkl\u00e4rt (ACLU v. Clapper, decision of 7 May 2015, Docket No. 14\u201042\u2010cv). Das heutige Urteil ist nicht [&hellip;]<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":3,"featured_media":0,"comment_status":"open","ping_status":"closed","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":[],"categories":[9,51],"tags":[122,266,457,326,458],"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.cr-online.de\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/2480"}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.cr-online.de\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.cr-online.de\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.cr-online.de\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/3"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.cr-online.de\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=2480"}],"version-history":[{"count":4,"href":"https:\/\/www.cr-online.de\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/2480\/revisions"}],"predecessor-version":[{"id":2580,"href":"https:\/\/www.cr-online.de\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/2480\/revisions\/2580"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.cr-online.de\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=2480"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.cr-online.de\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=2480"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.cr-online.de\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=2480"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}